The best part of this debate is the amount of wealth created by PE/PC/HF managers over the last 20 years on the backs of underfunded public pensions. If blue states managed their pensions better there would be less demand for alts and thus less billionaires. Damn teachers love PE
my position is
1. most billionaires earn their money legally
2. even if billionaires mostly "earn" their billions, i think that the concentration of wealth is a political, societal, and even economic problem. (for example: billionaire contributions to national elections could easily get to 25-50% of total political spend, and the power that implies over political and agenda capture makes me nervous; plus, at some point, concentration could move money from spenders to savers in a way that could be troublesome for growth)
3. recent tax cuts for s corps and c corps really don't help with (2)
4. to begin to address (2) i think we should undo the trump tax cuts, increase avg effective estate taxes, and probably raise the national minimum effective tax rate for the wealthiest ppl. it's too easy for billionaires to pay lower effective tax rates than the middle class with the c/s corp rules we have now