Over the last week the Joseph Wales studios and gallery in Margate ā my manorĀ ā exhibited a show by artist, critic and broadcaster Matthew Collings entitled āDrawings Against Genocideā.
Whether one considers the work good or not, it features many images which were caricatures of Jews, and which exhibited long-standing and well-known antisemitic tropes, such as āthe blood drinking Jewā, āthe Jew delighting in murderā, the child-murder Blood Libel, āJews as racistsā and imagery equating Zionism with Nazism. And, of course, the unsubstantiated turning of accusation of genocide on the victims of a genocide ā Jews ā is a ghastly libel.
Images in the exhibition also include āOctober 7th denialā, repeating false claims that there is no evidence of sexual violence committed by Hamas āfightersā and others during the invasion of southern Israel.
While I find the content of the exhibition and Collingsā work to be objectionable and hateful, and to inversely echo the well-known antisemitic exhibition of Degenerate Art of the late 1930s, I donāt believe the show should have been cancelled, let alone closed down.
But I do wonder how the artist, and the organisers and hosts of this exhibition think about their fellow citizens.
They appear not to have given a moment of thought to the effect of this exhibition and imagery on our Jewish friends and neighbours. It is fine to criticise or condemn the Israeli government for its actions, just as it is fine to criticise or condemn Hamas.
But the anti-Israel and anti-Zionist imagery and slogans in this exhibition were a ādog whistleā for racist antisemitism. Were such an exhibition to feature imagery of Palestinians or other Arabs, or of Muslims, it would rightly be called out by organisations such as Stand Up to Racism, and by politicians and other civic leaders. But Jews donāt seem to count in the hierarchy of discrimination and prejudice.
I have several Jewish friends, in Thanet and beyond, who are distressed by the attitudes, words and actions of many of those who consider themselves to be āpro-Palestinianā activists. And they are dismayed by hostile conversations they hear, and private messages they have received from people they considered friends. No doubt most would find this exhibition discomfiting at best.
The views exhibited by Collings and his supporters are of people who belive that the world is divided into the āgood peopleā ā them ā and the ābad peopleā, who it is virtuous to express hatred towards.
We need unity among citizens in our community, and to not allow this hate to divide us. I hope our politicians and other civic leaders will do more to condemn hatred towards our Jewish fellow citizens, and explain the threat of antisemitism to all of us.
JC writer
@realzoestrimpel visited Matthew Collingsā Drawings Against Genocide exhibition in Margate over the weekend. She was "shocked by the use of Nazi imagery."
Israelās charge dāaffairs said the drawings were "crude, aggressive, and completely indefensible" and should be "treated with the full seriousness of the law."
Full story online