A couple of people have asked me for my thoughts on the curriculum review leak about separate science, so in case anyone else cares:
- There are a lot of schools that could offer separate science, and choose not to (like Michaela Community School). These schools should offer it.
- There are a lot of schools that don't offer it, and maybe can't. You'd have to recruit at least one extra science teacher, and potentially run a loss if fewer than 20 students choose to take it. These schools will probably lose out from the leaked proposals.
- There are a lot of schools that offer it, but in lunch time, after school, or not as an additional optional block. I think this is inequitable, and they should not do this. It's one entire GCSE extra, and time should be allocated to it. It doesn't *look* from the proposals that this will be addressed.
- The separate science course as it currently stands is not a good course. There is stuff in it that could easily be removed, and with the exception of Space in physics there are no memorable units in the separate science course (in my opinion). One of the chemistry units is so bad that a number of my separate scientists told me that because of it they were no longer considering A Level chemistry.
- In terms of the science curriculum, there is a long list of things I think we should change. This is pretty low down the list. And in this submission to the review, co-signed by 560 science teachers and heads of science, it didn't even feature
achemicalorthodoxy.co.uk/202…
- In terms of science education in general, there is an even longer list of things I think we should change. Until we have high quality explicit instruction in every science classroom in the country, we will have a system that does not allow all students a true opportunity to pursue further studies in science. My strong opinion is that the best way to increase the number of students taking science at KS5 and beyond is to teach them better in KS3 and KS4. This is a big and difficult problem, but we shouldn't lose sight of it whilst other changes are taking place.
- Of course, this is just a snippet from the review. I think it's something that is broadly reasonable, and will have some impact. I definitely hope that there are other more substantial changes to come, like a reduction in content and a radical reassessment of the way exam boards interpret the national curriculum.