Lumping in Tristan Smith -- whose only crime was being too good to redshirt and being born a year too late for the Pavia waiver and a year too early for the new five-in-five rule -- with Sorsby is kind of gross.
And no, the Sorsby decision didn't enable the Smith decision.
The Sorsby decision was never about only one student-athlete. We are already seeing downhill effects in other eligibility cases in which state courts are allowing student-athletes to circumvent longstanding eligibility rules, citing Sorsby outcome as part of the court’s precedent.
Another example of why we need Congress to pass the Protect College Sports Act, authorizing the association to apply common sense eligibility rules consistently for all student-athletes and schools, regardless of the state or local court system.