The best traders today are leaning more discretionary than systematic.
Pure systematic edges hit a ceiling. The real outliers combine rules with judgment, adaptability, market feel, and razor-sharp risk management.
In the brand new Market Wizards: The Next Generation, Jack Schwager & George Coyle highlight that the top performers with the most spectacular returns are almost all discretionary traders.
Was discussing this exact topic below with
@rachit why manual execution and discretionary judgment have become the real core edge in today’s markets.
Manual execution is your edge over the hedge funds.
Trizzy on why retail traders actually have an edge over hedge funds in this market
"TA has never changed, the same profitable strategy still works to this day. But to be profitable in this market, you can't trade automatic. You're not trading entry, stop, TP anymore using that RR tool and actually making money. It's so rare to have an edge trading like that now"
"The hedge funds and prop firms that came in, they can't use manual execution, they're in positions too large to exit right away. So you have an advantage, you can exit whenever you want. A winning trade is a winning trade, sometimes I'll take 1K points off a fast move. You now have to actually understand what the price action means in the moment"