Norway is objectively better run. It has higher taxes than Alberta, it has better Elites than Alberta, it collects far more oil revenue per barrel then Alberta, it has better institutions than Alberta and it doesn't allow politicians to spend the money!
x.com/i/status/2020740411728…
Alberta populism has always presented itself as a politics of exclusion. Its central claim is that a productive province has been restrained by distant institutions and hostile interests, and that its failures are therefore best understood as injuries inflicted from outside. This narrative is emotionally satisfying. It is also false. Alberta has not been denied power within Canada. It has repeatedly refused to exercise it.
The province’s political culture has been shaped not by deprivation, but by fortune. Oil arrived quickly, revenues followed, and success preceded institutional maturity. Instead of building durable capacity, Alberta learned to posture. Grievance substituted for strategy. Protest displaced execution. Over time, opposition became an identity rather than a phase. Governance was deferred indefinitely.
This pattern repeated itself at every scale. Reform mobilized resentment without building a governing vehicle. Stephen Harper reached power with legitimacy and chose accommodation over confrontation. The structures Alberta populism claimed to despise were left intact, not because they were invincible, but because challenging them would have required a seriousness the movement never cultivated. When populism finally won, it evaporated.
Separatism is not a break from this tradition. It is its logical conclusion. Independence is proposed not as a plan to govern better, but as a way to avoid governing altogether. It promises control while surrendering leverage, and sovereignty while increasing vulnerability. It is sincerity without intelligence, and protest without responsibility.
What makes this failure more damning is that alternatives exist. Alberta could pursue industrial development, downstream manufacturing, and public capacity through crown corporations. It could convert extraction into industry and grievance into leverage. That it has chosen not to is the point.
This essay is not an attack on Alberta. It is an indictment of a political culture that mistook noise for power and never learned to govern.
Scouring the Albertan Separatist Shire
Now on Substack. (link in next post)