We need to talk about the biggest secret in veterinary medicine.
We all say we recognize non-human animals as sentient beings.
The Canadian Veterinary Medical Association even states it outright: animals feel pleasure, pain, fear, distress.
Cool. Gold star for humanity.
BUT what we believe on paper and what we practice in real life live on two different planets.
If youâre a golden retriever with a limp?
You get orthopedic surgery, laser therapy, underwater treadmill sessions, and a custom pain-management plan.
If youâre a dairy cow with mastitis?
You get âeconomically justified treatment.â
Translation: only if youâre still profitable as in shape up or ship out.
Weâve mastered compassion for the animals who sleep on our couches.
We even argue against declawing cats after learning how to do it in vet school.
Meanwhile, weâve become world-class experts at not looking too closely at the billions of animals living lives defined by confinement, pain, mutilation, and a slaughterhouse at the end.
We donât like to say out loud:
Veterinary medicine has two tiers.
Tier 1: Dogs, cats, and some horses: where welfare, pain, and quality of life matter.
Tier 2: âProduction animalsââwhere those same concerns are filtered through a single question: Does it affect yield ?
Horses sit in a tragic middle ground: cherished by some, disposed of by others, and quietly shipped to slaughter when they stop being âuseful.â
So why are we still training vets to accept conditions for industrially farmed animals that we would never tolerate for a dog?
You can hot-brand a calf without anesthesia, it's standard practice.
But stub out a cigarette on a dog?
You'll be reported, prosecuted, and publicly shamed.
Same pain. Different species. Different rules.
Because our profession was built to serve two masters:
animal welfare and animal agriculture.
And when those interests collide, guess which one wins?
We teach first-year students that animals are sentient.
The next year, we send them into factory farms to learn how to keep animals âproductiveâ in conditions weâd be reported for if we did the same to a Labrador.
We crusade against puppy mills for keeping dogs in cages.
Then we graduate vets to manage sow stalls where pigs can't even turn around.
We say animals deserve a life worth living.
We graduate vets who ensure animals survive just long enough to be profitable.
The cognitive dissonance isnât subtle.
Itâs massive.
I became a vet because I care about animals. All of them.
So why does my profession continue to teach me that some of them don't count?