Sceptical. Everyone promises similar reforms to business rates, until they see the numbers and the trade offs. If you want to fund a discount for hospitality, that requires additional money from somewhere else like any other tax cut.
Andy Burnham has made his first pledge for the Labour leadership - he said he will cut business rates for pubs and music venues by 20% if he becomes prime minister
He accused Sir Keir Starmer's government of "undervaluing" their importance to local communities after a succession of tax rises
When you stand back it's quite something and highlights the extraordinary dual nature of the Makerfield by-election.
He we have Burnham pledging a nationwide, £350million tax cut in the middle of a local campaign while criticising a Labour government
Burnham pledged to cut business rates by 20% in 2027-28 if he becomes prime minister at a cost of £100million
He also said that he will abolish business rates for cafes, shops and hairdressers if he enters Number 10 in a move that would cost a further £250million
He said he will fund it by increasing taxes on warehouses owned by tech giants such as Amazon and and tackling tax evasion on the high street
He said: “Our high streets matter to me because they matter to the people who live here. I want to make sure that these family-owned businesses, as the heart and soul of this country, are protected and given the chance to thrive.
“I am willing to be honest about where we have fallen short and say that my party has got it wrong in government. They have undervalued the contribution that these businesses make to our livelihoods and our communities.”