Energy Geek? Gamer? Ever wished these passions intersected? Check out the video demo below of my latest hobby project - a management simulator for operating a power network, PM me if your interested in getting a copy of the demo for play-testing!
youtube.com/watch?v=UPM98Qyg…
This is NESO conflating trading with NIV chasing, which is two different things. If I signal a physical position (i.e. FPN of 100) and spill (i.e.ECVN of 0) then I get paid the imbalance price, but I still have told NESO an accurate FPN, so no re-dispatch needed.
If we assume it has 10 years left (built in 2010) of CM payments left I think it would need £60/kW each year at an 85% de-rating factor to make back that £370mn. Which seems like a reasonably achievable outcome, with other revenues paying for Gas and Network charges. a
I know this is fruitless but I think we are agreeing here, Renewables are growing but they aren't going to displace gas entirely from the system by 2030, and my point is that breaking the link between gas and power prices is therefore difficult.
Also, where is the breaking of the link between gas and power? By the government own ambition gas will still be running in 50% of hours (generous reading 30% of the time?)
New GB wholesale mechanism being consulted on - the Wholesale CfD - RO genertors get to keep their ROCs, but exchange their current PPAs for a government backed one at a fixed price
Seems odd, as there would be little saving to the customer here, unless the generator accepted a WCfD with a haircut. A generator would be under a PPA with a discount to the day-ahead price, say 90%. So what discount would a generator be willing to accept for a longer agreement?
A ROC generator probably only has 15 years of useful life left, so the agreement length is probably around 10 years at least? We put the long-term PPA market for a index linked discount around 85% for a wind farm, so if thats where the market is offering the Govt has to be higher
What practical short-term options might exist for capping or de-linking gas from power prices? Three spring to mind from recent REMA discussions, converting RoCs to CfDs, iberian gas price caps and moving CCGT to a RAB model.
CCGT RAB: Make gas plant no-longer self dispatch, owners make gas plant available for NESO to dispatch at receive fixed payments. Doesn't necessarily remove gas price influence as other generators are well aware of what the gas cost is and when gas is running.
CPS is a tax on fuel at the gate, the £18/t duty is equivalent of £7-8/MWh based on the efficiency of the power station. As gas plant are normally the marginal fuel we would expect this to be reflected into a reduction in nearly all traded wholesale power products.
In markets dominated by Gas, or when nuclear output and renewables are lower, and demand higher we would expect to now increase our exports, and potentially increase our gas burn, reducing the overall impact of the measure.
Not to mention the gas price will come down by 2028 when this is implemented, so the impact would be much lower than if it were implemented immediately.