Canadian studies and comparative history

Joined August 2018
8,884 Photos and videos
Pinned Tweet
Lucas Alaman's "History of Mexico" tomes I & II are now available on Amazon. They cover the Mexican struggle for independence from the overthrow of the Bourbons by Napoleon in 1808 to the reduction of the rebellion to parts of the south in 1819 amzn.to/4fzs7mZ
7
32
235
22,061
people on this site were always being paid, but what made our sphere interesting was that none of our guys were. That changed a year & a half ago, & combined with suppression of threads ruined the dynamics.
3
5
128
3,534
There is one major new plus though - there are a lot more Africans on this site now. It's illuminating to read what they have to say on their states & regions.
5
65
2,172
funny to read about how exact same problems & scandals appear in quite different political systems. The FBI's raid on Trump's Florida dacha for the classified documents there; as well as suppression of Soufan, Agee, Shaffer, Snepp, Crowley, & Marchetti memoirs come to mind.
35
3,288
Thread with excerpts from "Russian Politics and Society" by Richard Sakwa
5
19
266
21,223
Russia as a delegative democracy - elections & pluralism are real even if manipulated, state & society are depoliticized, bureaucrats in executive offices are dominant class rather than any electoral party, market economy for small & medium-sized businesses but not large.
2
10
1,647
Extra-constitutional forces, particularly oligarchs, wielded a great deal of state power under Yeltsin. Putin's regime maintains certain extra-constitutional elements (banks, oil cos), but has built genuine institutions - particularly judiciary which now hears 16x more cases.
1
9
1,330
The 1,408 men who followed Cortes & Narvaez into Mexico were a high fraction of the Spanish population of Cuba. The total population was only about 20,000 in 1602, so was likely under 10,000 or even 5,000 in 1519.
2
17
347
12,398
Nemets retweeted
New ancient DNA paper in press by @HistArcDNA on Iron Age Mesopotamia! Read it here: link.springer.com/article/10…
3
21
93
7,021
Nemets retweeted
Based on discharge inscriptions, the Roman army retired around 150 veterans per 5,000 soldiers, representing about 3% of its troops each year. The military would also lose another 2% to natural rates of adult mortality. However, since somewhat less than half of all soldiers lived to complete their 25 years of service, the actual rate of mortality among soldiers was likely higher, at around 3%-4%. This means that each year the military lost around 6%-7% of its manpower to retirement and mortality. With an imperial army size of around 400,000 legionaries and auxiliaries, the Roman military required 24,000–28,000 new recruits simply to maintain its size. Each decade, this massive and complex military machinery would need to recruit, train, and churn out 240,000–280,000 new soldiers to defend the empire, essentially replacing most of the soldiery each decade.
15
52
671
41,885
Rome's haphazard political system at end of 2nd century left it with many redundancies, ensuring its resilience but allowing centralization under harsh emperors like Severus. The newly centralized system's stakeholders (high officials) then deliberately backed weak emperors.
4
4
100
4,824
The Roman gentry of Africa (modern Tunisia) survived through both the Vandal & Byzantine periods. It wasn't until the 11th century that they were fully swept away in an act of spite by the Fatimids.
17 Jul 2023
Replying to @Peter_Nimitz
While Iran’s high nobility lost power to the Arabs, the local gentry remained Persian. They & their descendants would preserve, synthesize, and advance Persianate culture. By contrast the old Roman gentry of Levant & Egypt seems to have been wiped out in the 602-628 bloodletting.
6
57
584
30,834
Part of a broader trend in MENA: women's literacy, internet use, & "relationship media" (for lack of a better description) are decreasing fertility.
Let me repost a post from last year, when I had fewer followers. Morocco’s TFR in 2024 was 1.97. In 2025 it was 1.90. A question for many readers who left comments: how is Morocco going to handle this in 2050? Not 2250, not 2150, but in one geneation.
11
21
394
23,339
Nemets retweeted
Palabras del príncipe heredero Hirohito: «México y el Japón son hermanos de la misma madre (...) cumplen igual misión en distintos continentes; son los guardianes de una civilización altamente moral, los centinelas de dos razas contra las fuerzas de la barbarie».
13
107
642
35,398
It's been correctly understood, deep down, by most English-Canadians that they are just a regional subgroup of Americans since the 1970s at latest. Only lack of vision on our part & loyalty to anti-American institutions on theirs keeps us separated.
The biggest thing allowing this to happen is that most Canadians do not care about Canadian history. Some of it is understandable on a demographic level (25% foreign born) but for the others it is an apathy that is hard to reverse.
25
28
399
26,887
wonder if Canadian regional identity would survive long though. Easy to see British Columbia becoming part of Pacific Northwest, Athabaska(?) part of the Mountain West, Prairies a part of the Great Plains, Ontario the Rust Belt, & the Maritimes New England.
5
2
67
3,337
Nemets retweeted
Jun 11
The Balkans weren’t always this Slavic. Before the 6th century, the region was mostly Roman provinces with Latin-speaking populations mixed with Illyrians and Thracians. Then everything changed. Starting in the 500s, Slavic tribes began crossing the Danube. At first they came as raiders with the Avars, but soon entire families started settling. They moved into the mountains and depopulated countryside, avoiding the big coastal cities. Over the next 200 years, they slowly took over most of the inland Balkans. The locals who survived either retreated to the highlands or were gradually absorbed. By the early Middle Ages, much of the peninsula had become what the Byzantines called “Sclavinia” — Slavic land.
43
55
476
57,917