I'm still surprised how many promotion candidates do not include their force Police Effectiveness, Efficiency & Legitimacy report (PEEL) as part of effective preparation ahead of promotion selection opportunities, which often include a PEEL themed presentation/briefing exercise.
At Rank Success for a decade plus, I've been signposting aspiring officers to their force PEEL report as one valuable resource because it’s a snapshot of performance across priority areas.
It's also full of golden nuggets to:
💡 Raise awareness
🤔 Support, challenge & provoke thinking
🧠 🚀 Close knowledge gaps & Boost confidence
Just this month I've spoken with candidates who've “heard of PEEL”, been involved in their force's remedy actions around areas 'highlighted for improvement' or 'areas of concern' & yet still completely unaware they can download (via HMICFRS website) a bespoke PDF summary of what their force does well (good to know). Perhaps it's not really so surprising awareness around PEEL is low, given ongoing challenges & other issues officers are dealing with.
But, if you are an aspiring leader & promotion candidate, the real value of PEEL in the context of a selection process is it highlights specific areas your force needs to improve e.g. for many forces right now, investigation is an area graded 'inadequate' or 'requires improvement'. Few are graded 'good'.
Before & after 'supportive conversations', once a candidate has had chance to read, absorb & reflect on their force PEEL report are different! Issues aligned to role expectations mean candidates can 'see' or predict where potential promotion board Qs or themes might come from
🎬 🎧 If you were not already aware of PEEL, you can find blogs, podcasts, your force PEEL video summary & more promotion support resources at Rank Success.
Here's a snapshot update of what’s occurring:
His Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary & Fire & Rescue Service (HMICFRS) have been busy inspecting forces & gathering evidence on their performance against its 'new inspection regime' since mid-2025. Reports started coming out last month, several more in pipeline for release, with other forces in inspection stage right now.
Here are the new core Qs used to assess all forces for this 2025-27 assessment framework period:
How good is the force at leadership & force management❓
How good is the force at attracting, developing & retaining its workforce & creating a diverse & inclusive workplace❓
How good is the force at using its powers fairly, appropriately & with justification❓
How good is the force at preventing & deterring crime, antisocial behaviour & vulnerability❓
How good is the force at responding to the public❓
How good is the force at investigating crime❓
How good is the force at safeguarding children & adults at risk of harm❓
How good is the force at managing fraud❓
How good is the force at providing a safe & lawful custody environment❓
📝 Blog link:
policepromotion.blog/2026/05…