ALT Shohei Ohtani NL MVP Pictured: Shohei Ohtani smiles while wearing a road gray Dodgers uniform. Below, Ohtani yells while wearing a home white Dodgers uniform. In the lower right corner is Ohtani’s signature in Japanese.

ALT Aaron Judge AL MVP Pictured: Aaron Judge smiles while wearing a road gray Yankees uniform. Below, Judge points to the sky while wearing a white pinstriped Yankees uniform. In the lower right corner is Judge’s signature.

ALT 2025 NL Cy Young Paul Skenes, Pittsburgh Pirates Paul Skenes’ signature is displayed in white script Pictured: A large cutout of Paul Skenes staring off into the distance, and a smaller cutout of an aerial view of Skenes delivering a pitch. In both, he is wearing a black Pittsburgh Pirates jersey and a black Pirates cap. 1.97 ERA 187.2 IP 216 Ks 6.5 fWAR