We should heed Tom‘s words here, because he should be seen as something of a triple threat related to this topic – he’s a republican; he works in public relations for a leading area firm; and most significantly, he’s a big New York Giants fan (one of the few Giants games I’ve ever attended was as Tom’s guest).
Let’s be clear. No one is saying that Jaxson Dart can’t be a Republican or for that matter of being a Trump supporter even in blue New York. But there are smarter and more discrete ways of showing that support. Dart did not employ those.
For example, if he had been invited to the White House, I’d tell him go right ahead. It’s an honor to be invited, regardless of who is the president.. Similarly, if President Trump invited Dart for a round of golf at one of his golf clubs, sure, go right ahead. But someone close to Dart should have told him that, not just attending a political rally featuring the president but actually introducing the president is a major mistake in the starting QB’s early career.
Tom mentions former Bills’ owner Ralph Wilson sending a note to Doug Flutie that he didn’t appreciate Flutie‘s campaigning for Hillary Clinton. Keep in mind, Flutie was well into his football career at that point as a veteran, but the optics were bad.
Dart must realize that once you become the quarterback for an NFL franchise, wherever you are, whatever the occasion is, you are representing that team. If you are in a public setting and are introducing somebody else or if you are the guest of honor, it’s not just about you. It’s about the organization that you represent. You are the public face of that organization. As an example, Dart might take a look at the team currently in Madison Square Garden and its leader. Jalen Brunson is always acutely aware when he opens his mouth that he is representing the New York Knicks and he is representing New York and speaking to their fans. Brunson is also a good interview. He doesn’t intentionally go out and make news, but still says something that shows, with humility, some of his personality (and he demonstrates that a little bit more on the podcast that he does with Josh Hart, “roommates”). Brunson is acutely aware that being the captain carries a certain sense of responsibility. If one of Dart’s advisors told him it was a good idea to appear at this rally, that advisor should be fired. If Dart heard that advice and just shrugged it off, that is a judgment error that perhaps should trouble the Giants front office, his coach and team owners.
Is there a double standard of sorts here? Sure. LeBron James regularly comments on political and social things and is divisive in way turning off half the country. On the other side, Aaron Rodgers makes various public announcements that turn off the other half. But both Hall of Fame-bound athletes have paid their dues. They’ve won NBA championships and a Super Bowl respectively. Both have won multiple MVPs. They are not second-year players who still have to prove themselves to their teammates, new coach and their fanbase. Like it or not, this Dart, ironically, has put a target on his back.
Once again, this is not an issue of whether athletes are allowed to have political views. Of course they are, but in these incredibly polarized times, judgment must be used. Dart didn’t display that judgment (by the way, a criticism that was previously directed at him in relation to his somewhat reckless running that led to him entering the NFL concussion protocol on more than one occasion).
Reminds me of when I was working for Gov Pataki. Flutie was with Bills and campaigning for Hillary’s Senate race in NY. Someone reminded Wilson he wanted money for his Stadium. Wilson sent letter to his QB telling him he pays him to play football and not politics.