Here's the majority of the suggestions I brought to the HAG. Also added that the advantage rule is overkill, and made a point on the maor foirne:
- Maor foirne should be allowed back in the game, but it's a 21-yard free to the opposition if that person impacts the game in any way (which is decided by the ref). Why will this work? Because teams will self-police, as they quickly have done with the dissent rule.
x.com/ShaneSaint/status/2055ā¦
Thereās a meeting tomorrow in Thurles on how the game of hurling can be improved, which is to be chaired by John Meyler and Willie Maher. Unfortunately I canāt make it, but sent the following suggestions. Let me know what you think.
KEEPER CANāT TAKE BALL IN HIS HAND FROM A BACK-PASS
- if the ball is passed back to the keeper during play, he may not take it into his hands. He can control it, strike it, whatever he likes, but canāt take it in his hands or even do a handpass off the stick. This will make it harder to recycle - meaning pressing high is more likely to cause exciting turnovers.
PUCKOUT OPTION TO ENCOURAGE MORE 50-50 CONTESTED HIGH BALLS
- ā for puckouts, each side must keep three players inside 21 (but outside the penalty box) closest to the keeper when the ball is struck. The puckout must also pass the near ā45. This will lead the less mass defences, and more 50-50 contested high balls.
- ā The unintended consequence could be teams bringing out their full-forward and full-back lines at the far end of the pitch. Worth trialling to see, as 50-50 high balls are a brilliant spectacle that we see less of.
CYNICAL FOULS ANYWHERE ON THE PITCH ARE PENALTIES
- ā all cynical tackles are punished by a penalty and a yellow card. Cynical tackles only occur when a team wants to prevent a move where a team wants to create a goal chance, so this is the only true deterrent. Too often, we see rugby tackles out the field late in games, and this would cut that out overnight. Youād expect this rule would rarely have to be used once teams see how (rightly) punitive it is.
PENALTY SPOT MARKER 25 YARDS OUT
- ā Penalties - paint a small line 25 yards out from where the ball must be lifted, and let the player jab and strike his penalty from however far forward he can take it from there. Brings back power penalties. Currently, you can see players more focused on not going past the ā21 than the strike.
NO QUICK PUCKOUTS
- Quick restarts after wides have turned the game into ping pong.
- ā Worth trialling, as Iām not convinced it will be a positive step.