YOU CANNOT SOLVE A HOUSING CRISIS BY CREATING A TOURISM CRISIS.
This week,
@HighlandCouncil is voting on a proposal to impose a region-wide short-term let (STL) control area.
Let me be clear: this is regulatory overkill. It adds yet more red tape to an already heavily regulated sector and will do nothing to address the root causes of the housing crisis.
* A Fundamentally Flawed Policy Objective:
Having spoken to the councillors behind this proposal on the radio over the last couple of days, it’s clear even they cannot define the specific mischief this policy is meant to address. Is it ‘overtourism’? A lack of housing? Too many ‘Airbnbs’? The rise in second homes? Long-term empty properties?
This confused rationale leads to a blunt intervention that will address none of these issues - while actively harming the local economy.
* No Evidence That STLs Are the Problem:
The facts don’t lie. Across the Highlands, there are nearly 11,000 long-term empty and economically inactive homes - far outnumbering self-catering units.
* BiGGAR Economics confirms: in every Scottish local authority, including Highland, empty homes have a far greater impact on housing supply than STLs.
* Failed Policy in Practice
The Badenoch & Strathspey control area, introduced in March 2024, is a cautionary tale. Over 200 applications overwhelmed the planning system, causing confusion and cost - with no evidence of even one new affordable home as a result. Why replicate failure at scale?
* The self-catering sector contributes £200 million annually to the Highland economy and supports almost 7,000 jobs. These are not faceless corporations. They're local families and microbusinesses, 70% run by women, 50% by people over 50, and 55% operating just one unit.
*A Sector Under Strain
Operators are already navigating complex licensing and planning regimes. Many are still reeling from recent changes.
* We Need Better Focus
STLs are an easy target, but not the real issue. The real challenges are:
- Chronic under-delivery of affordable housing
- Lack of new supply
- Thousands of empty homes
We need an evidence-led, joined-up housing strategy, not a knee-jerk response.
*To Highland Councillors: Please Think Again. This vote will not solve the housing emergency. It will damage small businesses, undermine rural economies, and worsen the situation. We need proportionate, targeted, effective regulation - not performative measures.
*Tourism and housing should work in balance, not in conflict. It’s time to stop scapegoating the self-catering sector and start addressing the true root causes of Scotland’s housing crisis.
hashtag#HighlandCouncil hashtag#SelfCatering hashtag#TourismMatters hashtag#STLs hashtag#HousingCrisis hashtag#Scotland hashtag#RuralEconomy hashtag#ResponsibleTourism hashtag#EvidenceBasedPolicy hashtag#ASSC
@ASSCnews @st_alliance @SaveSCScotland