Okay, the committee chose door #2 (below), or at least close to it. It was the right call.
It came down to Alabama, Miami and Notre Dame for two spots.
It was absolutely the right call to rank Miami ahead of ND, because of H2H. If you disagree, you're just flat wrong.
So, Bama vs ND. Bama was ranked ahead of ND last week, and would have stayed there without question if they hadn't played in the SEC champ game vs #3 Georgia. ND"s last game was, um, Stanford, and they didn’t have the risk on championship weekend that Bama did because they didnt play.
Yes, Bama got smoked. But choice #2 below was to honor champ games.
ND had a playoff-worthy season. But there are only 12 spots, and they were first team out. It was the correct call.
We'll find out today what the committee thinks about a choice between two bad options.
1. Reward a team that didn't play in it's conf champ game, at the expense of a team that did play but lost.
2. Don't use a loss in a conf champ game in the ranking process.
Both options have a lot to hate. I think we should err on the side of favoring conf champ participants.
What do you think?