If someone claims a new law of physics, the correct response isnโt to brush it off, but also not to accept it on assertion. Physics advances through clear definitions, mathematical formulation, consistency with existing theory, and experimental or logical support.
Iโm always open to new ideas, but until a proposal is clearly formulated and evaluated, itโs reasonable to remain cautious. Being open-minded and being critical are not opposites, theyโre both required.