I watch money move for a living. Where it comes from, where it goes, who’s actually building something and who’s just shuffling it around the table. So let me say something about the people who think wealth is a fixed pile sitting there waiting to get divided up fairly.
The anti-capitalista have got it backwards. All of it.
The whole worldview runs on one assumption.. the economy already exists, in full, and the only real question is who gets which slice. Take from the people who have it. Give to the people who decide. Call it fairness and move on.
Johan Norberg wrote a whole book on why that’s nonsense. The Capitalist Manifesto. One line in it does most of the work.. “wealth has to be created before it can be distributed.”
Sounds obvious. Apparently it isn’t. Because the entire redistribution pitch skips the front half of that sentence and acts like the wealth was just.. there. Like it fell out of the sky and somebody hoarded it before you got to the table. Nobody made it. Nobody risked anything. It simply exists, and now we fight over who deserves it.
That’s bullshit. They’ve got people believing that slicing the pie thinner is the same thing as baking a new one. It’s not. You can redistribute until the end of time and never create a single new dollar. Eventually somebody has to actually make the thing.
And people did. That’s what drives the losers up a wall.
Extreme poverty went from something like four out of ten people on earth to under one in ten.. in a single generation. No committee pulled that off. No five year plan. Markets did. Trade did. People who put their own money at risk did. The same entrepreneurs everyone’s supposed to resent now were putting electric cars and cheap shipping and reusable rockets in front of millions of people long before a politician showed up to explain how greedy they’d been.
And here’s what that side never wants to admit. Capitalism isn’t soft on the rich. Norberg again.. “Capitalism is merciless against capitalists who do not deliver.” Stop creating value and you’re finished. No bailout. No protected seat. Nobody propping you up. That brutality is the entire point of the whole thing. What these people actually hate isn’t capitalism, it’s cronyism.. the rigged version where the government hands out the winners. Two completely different animals. They need you to think they’re the same one, because that confusion is about the only thing holding the argument together.
So next time the noise kicks up.. billionaires shouldn’t exist, wealth is theft, claw it all back.. look at what’s really going on. It has nothing to do with helping poor people. Poor people have never in human history done better than they’re doing right now, under the exact system getting torched. It’s the oldest move there is. Stir the resentment, make the success look dirty, teach everyone that any money made outside the state is suspect by default.
Don’t build. Don’t risk. Don’t want more. Not unless somebody signs off first.
That’s the real pitch, under all of it.
Norberg’s answer is the same thing I’ve been saying for years. Quit listening to the prophets. Watch the data. And the data’s been telling you the same story the whole time.. creation beats confiscation, and it’s not close.
Ps. Fuck communism.