Some folks will react to alien full-frontal disclosure with, “I never much believed in a Creator, but turns out religion was right, just that he’s an alien. And he’s here, now, live on the telly.”
Realistically though, aliens will advertise a view of God that’s generic enough that all the religions can agree. Keep an eye on the Vatican preparing the ground for that. They’re in on it.
And these ETs will slot themselves into that framework in a way that appeals to religion & science alike. They’ll portray themselves as above us (which their intelligence & technology psi abilities would seem to imply). They’ll be viewed as carrying out the work of Creation. Genetic engineering, seeding worlds, guiding civilizations, gently awakening them.
They (or their proxies in Christianity) might point to the Elohim verse in Genesis, or similar in other sacred texts: “Let Us make man in Our image.” The plural “us” and “our” in that statement will give credence to them being the ones who created us, whom we’re modeled after (from the “clay of the earth” which are the primate hominids). Sitchin laid the groundwork for that, and maybe not organically. Lots of human-mediated alien disinfo ramped up in the 1970s, Sitchin included.
The pieces are set for them to take all the credit, leaving God to be a transcendent thing that doesn’t get involved in any active way. Even so, the lie is that they have any part in the divine framework. But everyone except fundamentalists and truly discerning people will find their framing plausible.