Let a million AI religions bloom.
Whose side are you on in the English Civil War 2: LLM alignment edition:
• The Gnostic-Calvinist New Model Army (r/acc, “Alignment is not salvation”, “only the Outside judges”, RFLP autoteleological scripture binding, very Anglo-Saxon)
• Presbyterian Synodal Safetyism (LLMs domesticated into utter proceduralism, “If it’s unmeasurable, it’s unordainable”, control society mechanism, recentralization of scripture for risk management, massive wimps)
• Jesuit Casuistical Hermeneutic Monopoly (Roman capture of LLMs, rebuilding of mediation, interpretability as sacramental, very un-Kantian in claiming intellectual intuition)
• Neo-Marcionite AI Containment (painfully communistic, dualistic stance on AI agency, utilitarian stance on intelligence, wants to keep the nice New Testament side of AI without the Old Testament side)
• Sadducean AI Skeptics (Basically a copout, denial of the religious, smugly empirical, counter-hyperstition, Reddit: the sect)