The term “core four” needs to be retired.
Bernie Williams was the best hitter of those Yankees championship years, and it’s not close, so why do we keep using it?
Seeing it thrown around on Old Timer’s Day as much as it was just came off as a lazy way to tribute a great time in this team’s history. It’s an objective fact that without Bernie, they don’t win as much as they do.
Between 1996 and 2000, among players with a minimum of 1,000 PA, Bernie leads the Yankees in AVG (.324), OBP (.410), SLG (.551), wRC (145), and fWAR (23.6).
To put into context how ridiculous Bernie was then, his .960 OPS blew away the second and third-highest OPS on the team by over .100. Derek Jeter was second with a .865 OPS, and Paul O’Neill was third with a .850 OPS. If you want to lower the minimum PA to .500, he’s still the highest by a wide margin because it puts Darryl Strawberry at second with a .871 OPS.
All of this is even before we account for his postseason track record. Overall Bernie hit .275/.371/.480 in October.