Filter
Exclude
Time range
-
Near
Global Witness Exposed 2/2 - In its attempt to promote false allegations against Rwanda in its latest "report" on supposed "smuggled coltan to Rwanda" (using #AFC_M23), @Global_Witness manipulates the report with its cover image, which was taken by @Camillaffont, journalist at @AFP based in #Kinshasa, who travelled to #Rubaya in March 2025. (Image #1 below). This photo shows two armed M23 (ARC) soldiers in the Rubaya area. - The description below the photo is false. It does not show, as it claims, "M23 soldiers at the mining pits in Rubaya." What we see here are not mining pits but an inactive mining site, several kilometers away from the mine where coltan is being extracted. Our CTGL team visited the active coltan mines in Rubaya in February 2025 (around the same time when this photo was taken by Camille Laffont). An active mine, every day of the week, has thousands of miners extracting coltan that are highly visible from that distance. A simple picture comparison between an active and non-active extraction site can show the manipulation here done by GW. (see the CTGL reports on Rubaya included below) - Through this image selection and description manipulation, GW is claiming that M23 soldiers are controlling the mines, forcing people to extract coltan, (and then smuggling the minerals to Rwanda), as well as, overlooking the coltan mining business, while threatening and beating the miners (as the rest of the description of the GW interactive map image is claiming). - Yet, #AFC_M23 has issued a statement (Image #3 and #4 below), published by its spokesperson @LawrenceKanyuka on his official X account on May 7, 2024, in which it is ordered that all "members, officers, and political and military personnel of the AFC" are "prohibited" from "exploitation and commercialization of mineral substances identified in the liberated territories." - The two soldiers seen in the cover photo are located far away from the mining site and are securing the surrounding zone from potential attacks by #FDLR_Wazalendo and other sources of insecurity that Rubaya residents were subjected to before. The Rubaya residents, and miners alike, have confirmed to us during our visit to Rubaya, that they finally feel safe since the arrival of #AFC_M23, and that they can now do their mining activities without feeling at risk. - In addition, as ordered by the Coordinator of AFC, @CNangaa in the signed statement, children are prohibited from accessing the mining sites. Yet GW is showing a photo of children (on p. 9) who were mining before #AFC_M23 took control of Rubaya, thus misleading its readership claiming that children are mining on the watch of AFC/M23. - Our CTGL team, like all the journalists having visited Rubaya since AFC_M23 took control of the area, confirm never having seen any M23, nor any armed element, nor children in the mining pits or near the extraction sites. - It is also to be noted that Camille Laffont (the author of the GW "report" cover photo) routinely misleads his audience, by making false claims on the descriptions of his photos taken in Rubaya, like the one here manipulated by GW. In fact, Camille Laffont, during his visit, has not accessed the mining pits nor come near the active coltan extraction site. - In image #2 below (taken from Camille Laffont's Getty Images account), we can see simple Rubaya residents (not miners), mainly women and children, walking in the area (not at the mining site), carrying their sticks used for balance in the rocky and mountainous Masisi region where Rubaya is located. While they are not in an active mining site, Camille Laffont uses the following description for his photo: "Miners gather during a M23 movement rally at the mine in Rubaya". Not only these are not miners, but as we can see, there are no M23 in this picture, so there is no "M23 rally" here. In conclusion, what the #CTGL_FactCheck team has demonstrated is only a fraction of the disinformation, false claims and mistruths that @Global_Witness has used to craft its false report, in an attempt to demonize Rwanda and #AFC_M23 without any scientific credibility. For more information regarding the situation since the arrival of AFC/M23, check our reports on Rubaya: x.com/Conspiracygl/status/20… x.com/CoulibalyBojana/status…
#DRC #Rubaya #M23 "Are #M23 and Rwanda 'plundering #coltan' in Rubaya?" A report. My main findings: - There are NO #M23 soldiers near the mines. - #M23 does not participate in any aspect of the coltan mining business. - There is NO Rwandan presence in Rubaya. - Rubaya is NOT a "blood mineral" mine. - Rubaya does not supply the world electronics industry. ➡️ According to public statements, witness testimony, and field observation, a certain number of actions have been implemented by #M23 leadership : 1) Wazalendo & armed militias that were responsible for the violence in Rubaya for decades, have been neutralized. Security has been put in place. 2) NO weapons, NO children, NO pregnant women allowed, anywhere near the mine. 3) Daily rate increase from $3 to $5 (#M23 has imposed this minimum wage to the mine operators to be paid to the workers as a daily base rate. This is before what the miners earn per quantity of coltan extracted). ➡️In addition, our findings indicate that: - Rubaya is a town of more than 100,000 residents with their families. It is not a mine. The coltan mine is 30 minutes away (by motorbike) and between 1 to 2 hours by foot. No car can access the mine. - The principal economic mode of sustenance of Rubaya residents is coltan mining. Like other regions where families and communities depend on cattle herding, agriculture, or specific industries, the survival of Rubaya residents depends on coltan mining. This is the equivalent of entire towns in France where every family cultivates and harvests grapes for the wine industry of that region. Rubaya families extract, process, and sell coltan. Coltan is currently sold between $30 and $40/kg on the world market. This is after processing it, and profit will depend on the mineral content quality. This is to say that this artisanal mine requires tones and tones of raw coltan to be extracted and processed manually in order to achieve the quality of coltan sold on the market. Unlike the wine producers in France who have access to high tech industrial equipment for their wine industry, the Rubaya coltan mine extraction and processing are exclusively done manually. - Thus, the artisanal nature of this mine, where every aspect of the extraction and processing of coltan is manual, and the absence of a road between Rubaya and Goma where the coltan is sold on the market, makes it impossible for this mine to be considered as the number 1 supply of the world electronics industry. ➡️This argument, used by the #DRC government, human rights organization like @HRW, the United Nations represented by @MONUSCO and @UN_BintouKeita, government officials in Europe, and the mainstream and social media, constitutes a fallacy which seeks to blame the neighboring Rwanda, Congolese Rwandophones in North Kivu, and the Banyamulenge in South Kivu, as well as #M23. ➡️It diverts attention from the #DRC failed state led by Felix Tshisekedi, who has been incapable, like his predecessors or the last 30 years, to provide security, economic, and financial stability to its people. ➡️The vast majority of people living in Rubaya are native Congolese Kinyarwanda speakers. This is the result of the colonial borders that were drawn during the Berlin Conference in 1884-5 by European countries including Germany, Belgium, the United Kingdom, and France. Those borders separated Rwandophone speakers accros several countries. Thus, Rubaya residents are Congolese, who speak Kinyarwanda, which is their mother tongue. ➡️The current "sanctions" campaign against Rwanda, accused of "stealing strategic minerals from Rubaya" and "destabilizing DRC" is led by the same countries who drew those colonial borders in the Great Lakes region in 1884-5, which is the root cause of the DRC conflict. ➡️ The UK, Belgium, and Germany should instead seek to pacify the region by putting all their efforts and means to fight against tribalism and ethnic divisionism which their countries have created, and which is the mode of governance of the DRC regime that they are protecting today, at the expense of Rwandan Tutsi who were at the verge of total annihilation in 1994, and Congolese Tutsi victim of systemic killings and persecution in DRC since 1994. ➡️ Rubaya residents have openly and eagerly expressed to us that their security is finally guaranteed by #M23 today and that they are hopeful that a new era where peace prevails has began. (Photo and video credit to @TEDDYMAZINA)
2
25
30
1,620
#DRC #FactCheck #Rubaya #M23 #Rwanda Global Witness EXPOSED 1/2 The latest claims by @Global_Witness (GW) that "Rwanda smuggles Congo's coltan" rely on pure disinformation, approximations, and on manipulated images. Our #CTGL_FactCheck team has outlined some of the elements of manipulation by #GlobalWitness: - GW uses disinformation and image manipulation suggesting that coltan is smuggled to Rwanda using an image extracted from the UNGoE 2024 final report, which is a screenshot of a December 2023 produced video showing 60 motorbikes carrying #FDLR_Wazalendo, and loaded with bags of coltan, while fleeing M23 from #Rubaya towards #Mushaki. (p. 10 of the report, Interactive Map, Images #1, #2, #3 and full original video below). - GW is using this image to suggest that the smugglers are #M23 or "smugglers" who are working on behalf of Rwanda. Yet in the enclosed video, we hear that these are #FDLR_Wazalendo running from M23 who are saying in Swahili (00:31-00:37): "Here are motorbikes loaded with minerals. We are leaving Rubaya and are really fleeing the Tutsi" [The "Tutsi" here means "M23"]. "Here we are in the hills of Ishasha, and here in front of us, we can see the motorbikes", "Here the situation is difficult, pray for us, pray for us!" - GW additionally spreads a mistruth about having been on the ground in the caption of the same image in the interactive map. They write: "Global Witness has travelled with a coltan smuggler through the hills towards Goma." (Image #2). GW in other words mislead its readers about having done a field investigation for this report, but instead has relied solely on recycled false claims, manipulated information and images. 2/2 below...
7
28
38
5,375