Whereas sunnah dotcom is making the hadith grading look like an objective issue. Massive disservice to the science of hadith. Muslims and non-muslims blindly rely on their gradings
Shaykh ‘Muhammed bin ‘Alawi al-Maliki al Hasan said:
“The scholars differ concerning many Hadith, and they refute each other in authentication, weakening, or rejecting them due to their differing views concerning the strength of the chains of narration and the critique of the men (in the chain).
Whoever among them authenticates that which is weak, weakens that which is authentic, establishes the authenticity of that which is rejected, or rejects that which is established, all with evidence, interpretation, or what resembles proof, then he has traversed the path of the scholars in research and investigation.
That is his right as a human who possesses his own intellect and understanding. The sphere is open, the field is expansive, and the knowledge is spread among all.”
[Notions That Must Be Corrected by Shaykh Muhammed b. ‘Alawi al-Maliki al-Hasani pg. 160]