WHEN THE GOVERNMENT DOES NOT WANT TO INVEST IN REAL, SCIENTIFIC, GROUND-LEVEL SOLUTIONS, IT REACHES FOR SHORTCUTS!
And throughout India’s stray dog crisis, the two biggest shortcuts have always been the same:
Remove the dogs, or kill the dogs!!
Now, under the language of “public safety” we are watching another shortcut being packaged as policy.
The Supreme Court directive suggesting the REMOVAL OF DOGS FROM A LIST OF PUBLIC PLACES for stray dogs is being presented as an efficient administrative solution. But it is not a solution at all. It is what governments do when they do not want to fix the actual system.
Because fixing the system would require work.
It would require properly funded ABC programs.
1. Mass sterilization.
2. Vaccination drives.
3. Veterinary recruitment.
4. Waste management reform.
5. Long-term population monitoring.
6. Local implementation that actually functions.
Instead, administrations across the country have allowed these systems to collapse for years.
Look at Karnataka’s own district-wise data from January 2022 to November 2025.
Major districts including Bengaluru Urban, Chitradurga, Gadag, Kalaburagi, and Yadgir recorded zero dog sterilizations and zero veterinarians deployed over multiple years.
Zero!
Not low numbers. Not partial implementation. Nothing.
Other districts were barely functional. Vijayapura managed just 45 sterilizations in nearly four years.
This is not an uncontrollable dog crisis!
This is administrative abandonment!
And rather than admitting that failure, the state keeps searching for ways to simply remove dogs from public visibility.
That is why every few years the conversation circles back to mass relocation, indefinite confinement, or outright killing.
Because removal is cheaper than governance.
Killing is cheaper than infrastructure.
Confinement is cheaper than public health planning.
And now gaushalas are being dragged into this same logic of disposal.
But these shelters are already collapsing.
At Bhopal’s Jeev Daya Gaurakshan Kendra, official records showed annual cattle mortality rates as high as 54.5%, with 1,317 cattle deaths in a single year. The previous year was worse: 1,690 deaths out of 2,181 animals.
In Goa, a 2025 state audit found that 2,814 cows died across eight government-funded gaushalas within three years despite crores being sanctioned for upkeep.
A nationwide FIAPO assessment found severe overcrowding, chronic tethering, lack of movement, and massive infrastructure deficits across gaushalas in 13 states.
We are talking about facilities where animals are already dying in huge numbers.
And the proposed answer is to push territorial, free-ranging dogs into these same failing spaces to reduce the “operational burden” on municipalities.
This is not animal welfare!!
It is not science!
It is not rabies control!
It is a visibility-management strategy!
The goal is not to solve the problem. The goal is to make dogs disappear from public spaces without investing in the systems required for humane population management.
The tragedy is that India already has the framework for humane control: sterilize, vaccinate, and return.
But that requires functioning governance!
Shortcuts are easier!
And animals pay the price for every one of them!
Credits to
@JahnaviIyer for the data!
@APsmindset
@bkshivani @gaurgopald @satnamsandhuchd @kang_malvinder @gurmeetkhuddian @Adiv_pste_morbi @CMOGuj
@sanghaviharsh @AmitShah @narendramodi
@BJP4Gujarat @GujaratPolice @GujaratTourism
#StopAnimalCruelty #BeKindToAnimals #AnimalRights #saveindiafromdoghaters #JusticeForStrays #StopAnimalCruelty #Accountability #AmendPCA #NoMore50 #SaveIndianDogs #awaranahihamarahai
@rashtrapatibhv @THaPriYa123 @JahnaviIyer
@dilthi_gujarati @DDNewslive @ndtv
@DoahGujarat @dgpgujarat @jigneshmevani80
@Gopal_Italia @ssagpariya @VHPDigital
@BajrangDalOrg @RSSorg @BJPDrMadhavDave
@irammokariya @karuna_rajkot @GPSCforChange