Barry Fell (full name Howard Barraclough Fell, June 6, 1917 – April 21, 1994) was a British-born zoologist and marine biologist, best known for his later work in controversial pseudohistorical and epigraphic theories about pre-Columbian contact between the Old World and the Americas.
Background and Credentials
• Fell earned a Ph.D. from the University of Edinburgh (1941) and was a respected expert on echinoderms (particularly fossil sea urchins).
• He taught at Victoria University of Wellington (New Zealand) before joining Harvard University’s Museum of Comparative Zoology in 1964 as a professor of invertebrate zoology, where he worked until retiring in 1979.
• His early interest in inscriptions included a 1940 study of Polynesian petroglyphs, but he had no formal training in archaeology, linguistics, or epigraphy (the study of ancient inscriptions). Critics often highlighted this mismatch when evaluating his later claims.
Major Books and Claims
Fell gained public attention in the mid-1970s with popular books promoting “diffusionist” ideas—that advanced Old World civilizations (Europeans, Africans, Asians) visited, traded with, and colonized the Americas thousands of years before Columbus (and even the Vikings). He based these primarily on his interpretations of rock carvings, petroglyphs, and artifacts as ancient scripts.
• America B.C.: Ancient Settlers in the New World (1976):
This was his breakthrough book, timed for the U.S. Bicentennial. Fell argued for extensive pre-Columbian contact, claiming evidence of Celtic (Irish/Scottish) mariners and settlers in North America as early as ~3,000 years ago. Key claims included:
• Translations of supposed Ogham (early medieval Irish stroke-based script) inscriptions on rocks in New England and elsewhere, interpreted as Celtic languages.
• Phoenician, Iberian, and other Old World influences.
• Sites like Mystery Hill (New Hampshire) as Celtic temples or observatories.
• Linguistic links, such as Algonquian (e.g., Micmac) scripts or words deriving from Egyptian hieroglyphs or Celtic terms.
The book mixed adventure narrative, linguistics, and anthropology, suggesting Native American cultures were heavily shaped (or overshadowed) by these visitors.
• Saga America (1980):
A sequel expanding on the first book with more “evidence.” It proposed even broader contacts:
• Carthaginian, Phoenician, Libyan, Roman, Jewish, North African Christian, Islamic, and Viking visits/settlements over millennia.
• Specific claims like St. Brendan (Brendan of Clonfert) reaching North America centuries before Columbus, based on interpreted Ogham inscriptions in West Virginia (e.g., narrating Christ’s nativity).
• A detailed chronology of transatlantic voyages, trade (e.g., copper), and cultural exchanges.
• Libyan maps and inscriptions in the American West, and further ties to Algonquian peoples.
He followed up with Bronze Age America (1982), focusing on Scandinavian/Bronze Age visitors (e.g., a voyage by “Woden-lithi” around 1700 B.C. to trade in Ontario).