This post really drove home the current predicament
@solana finds themselves in right now.
The whole reason they are doing industrial grade door to door shilling for
@PhoenixTrade and skipped over
@pacifica_fi is because they don't just need a perp dex on Solana, they need a perp dex that fixes the dumpster fire tokenomics that
$SOL currently has.
@0xasrequired made the very key point that Pacifica is no more aligned with
$SOL than
@Lighter_xyz is with
$ETH or
@HyperliquidX is with
@arbitrum. There are Pacifica points, there will be a Pacifica airdrop for a Pacifica token. Very little value accrual to
$SOL even if Pacifica rivals Hyperliquid.
Phoenix explicitly states there is no points or airdrop. Gas fees use
$SOL, and it's entirely possible/likely that transaction fees will have some value accrual to
$SOL too.
This is very different from the parasitic relationship that
@Pumpfun has with
$SOL where they just sell all their
$SOL to buyback and burn
$PUMP.
$SOL currently trades around a 300x 30d annualized fee/mcap ratio vs the 16x ratio that
$HYPE trades at. The argument that general purpose blockchains deserve to trade at 20x the ratios that perp dexes are trading at is no longer compelling to investors, as evidenced by
$HYPE making ATH vs
$SOL for a year straight.
The reason the SOL foundation is shilling Phoenix specifically like it's do it die is because for them, it IS do or die. They prioritized memes for too long, and lost sight of their initial mission: perps. If they don't become competitive on perps, specifically with a specifically
$SOL aligned perps dex, they'll continue to bleed valuation.
Composability with a chain only counts if the chain actually has a useful DeFi ecosystem, otherwise it's just a buzzword.
The good news for them is they currently have the best ecosystem for spot equities and their stablecoin ecosystem is trending in the right direction, which will eventually be important.
The battle lines for the next 12 months are very clearly drawn.
@solana needs to throw
$SOL incentives at onboarding perps DEX users and make up lost ground (or continue door to door shilling).
@HyperliquidX needs to throw
$HYPE incentives to make up lost ground wrt building out a relevant DeFi ecosystem (money markets, liquid staking, spot equities etc).
$ETH needs to make the same realization that
$SOL made, albeit way too late; it sucks to be a public good general purpose blockchain.
I think
@HyperliquidX has a much cleaner path to their win condition than
@solana, so the HYPE/SOL pair trade (L/S) is very thematic here. ETH foundation is so asleep at the wheel that they aren't even in the conversation here. Over the next year, both
$SOL and
$ETH likely continue to bleed market cap to
$HYPE, and select
$HYPE eco tokens might finally catch an outsized bid.
It's a big if, but IF SOL can undo the damage (Phantom using HL builder codes is a permanent black eye for them), SOL/ETH L/S is very compelling for the next 12 months. Near zero reason to bet against HYPE at this point imo. Their fight to lose.