This debate is entirely confused. What the NYT editorial doesn't show is that progressives basically never run in those purple districts. Of 22 Democratic incumbents who lost their seats between 2016 and 2024, 21 were moderates.
From Bonica's response today (link below)
You’d think if the “avoid moving to the center on social issues and just go really hard left on economic issues” strategy worked out there would be at least one Democrat holding a seat in a Trump district who adhered to it but nope