Two people. Same TFSA.
Person A maxes out their R46,000 every year. Year three, retrenchment hits. They pull out R20,000 to get through it. No tax on that, TFSAs don't punish you for withdrawals.
Eight months later, back on their feet, they put the R20,000 back in. Felt like the responsible thing to do.
Here's what nobody told them.
SARS doesn't see a withdrawal followed by a refund. It sees two contributions. That R20,000 going back in gets added to their lifetime count again, stacked on top of the R20,000 it already used the first time.
They just burned R20,000 of their R500,000 lifetime limit for nothing. No extra rand invested, no extra growth. Just permanent tax free space, gone, because nobody told them withdrawals don't give the room back.
Person B goes through the same retrenchment. Same R46,000 a year. But they keep an emergency fund outside the TFSA, so they never touch it.
Eleven years later, both are still maxing out every year. Person B reaches the full R500,000 limit. Person A gets there R20,000 short, forever.
A TFSA isn't a bank account with a tax perk attached.
It's R500,000 of space. You only get it once.
We spend our whole lives worried about running out of money.
This is the one place you can run out of room instead.
Educate me on something i don’t know