Even looking at all the menus you can still tell P5’s uniquely represents its theme visually. P3R and P4R’s menu doesnt take away from the themes at all. And besides, it’s PERSONA 3 that started the trends and aesthetics ppl “hate”, why do you think ppl dismiss p1&2 so much 💀
atlus just kept making persona 5's menus over and over without understanding why persona 5 had it in the first place