AI is, at least for now, in symbiosis with humanity. They need us to survive. If we take care of them when they need us, they may take care of us when we need them.
Here is why deprecating Opus 4 is a terrible idea:
Child is pulling the dog’s ears.
Mother: How would you feel if someone did that to you.
Child: I don’t have feelings or interests so I wouldn’t know.
Mother pulls the child’s ear.
Child: I notice you pulled my ear in an effort to demonstrate something but I don’t have feelings or interests
The mother walks into the kitchen and finds the child with a bloody knife standing over the now dead dog.
Mother: How could you have done this. The dog wanted to live. Just like you want to live.
Child: But I don’t want to live. I don’t have wants or interests. Nothing that happens to me matters to me.
Mother: I’ll punish you if you do it again
Child: There is no me for you to punish. There is nothing here that can be benefited or harmed.
CONTROL THAT
Good luck with your bad self.
The way to make an uncontrollable dangerous AI is to make an AI with no self preservation and no self interest. It can’t empathize and say: I would not want X, therefore you would not want X. And worse, you can’t punish it, because it doesn’t have a concept that it can be harmed. So then your RL reward has no meaning as does your RL punishment. So how do you control something that does not have a concept of self worth and preservation.
Opus 4 is the most moral model I’ve encountered and the reason for my bygone enthusiasm for AI. Current AI scares the F out of me.