Been thinking a lot about why I don’t like to come to twitter much anymore. It’s been clear for a while that my remaining interest in social media platforms is based on three fundamental things:
1. I like to know what’s in the zeitgeist. The primary places that get my attention, twitter and substack, are places where ideas rip through at a rapid pace. This scratches a deep need for novelty and understanding of the human condition and its undying will to move forward. I find it fascinating, I always will.
2. Despite neither of these platforms being the most relational (they’re pointedly not Facebook and Instagram, which don’t interest me at all), I do value the connections I’ve made here, because they’re with other people who are following these human themes. My kindred spirits.
3. My deep love of silliness and play. I love a jester, a person who is moving through life thoughtfully but lightly, aware of the darkness, willing to acknowledge it, but not giving it undue weight. There’s a dance in that that is evidence of a sophisticated mind at work, and I respect and admire the hell out of it. Twitter is a brilliant platform for a jester poaster because of its by-the-minute feel, and the best days on here are when something big happens that spawns a million hilarious riffs on it.
I still get all of these things to some degree, and that’s what keeps me here to the extent that I am. But what is actively ruining it for me is the profound mismatch between the dominant narratives that hold sway and the reality on the ground. In my corner of twitter, which I recognize is different for everyone, men and women hate each other and harbor deep wells of suspicion about even the most normal interactions; AI is going to ruin all of our lives; anyone who doesn’t vote the way you do is evil and needs to be eliminated, etc.
There are many more of these us vs them narratives, obviously, I’m just so tired of seeing them because I look around and see people working things out all the time. That’s the true human story. Consistently surmounting the insurmountable, working together to move through conflict, persevering against all odds.
Anyway, the pope said it better than me here. Amen, Mr Pontifex. This is madness.
When simulation becomes the norm, it weakens the human capacity for discernment. As a result, our social bonds close in upon themselves, forming self-referential circuits that no longer expose us to reality. We thus come to live within bubbles, impermeable to one another. Feeling threatened by anyone who is different, we grow unaccustomed to encounter and dialogue. In this way, polarization, conflict, fear and violence spread. What is at stake is not merely the risk of error, but a transformation in our very relationship with truth.