My brother and I quit our 6-figure jobs in tech to start an ice cream brand.
This is part 1 of the story of building Natty Ice Cream. I'm taking you back to July-Dec of 2024.
But one full year before starting Natty, Garrett and I were both overweight.
We committed to eating clean, working out, and we lost a combined 100 pounds. Unfortunately, that meant cutting out ice cream.
Everything in the store was either packed with sugar and fat and didn't fit our macros, or used nasty synthetic ingredients we didn't recognize.
So we both started making our own ice cream at home with the Ninja Creami.
After a few weeks, I got tired of making it on a daily basis. So I went on another search.
I couldn't find anything in stores that was close to what what we were making at home (high protein, low sugar, clean ingredients).
And we figured we couldn't be the only ones looking. So my brother and I decided to build it ourselves and get it on grocery store shelves.
For the first six months we were working in our apartment kitchens and tested over 100 recipes.
The early batches were bad. Chalky, icy, and tasted no better than a protein shake. But we kept going until our friends and family actually liked what we were making.
During this process, we also developed the Natty brand. We spent a lot of time thinking through the brand we wanted to build. It needed to embody the standards we cared about, the lifestyle we live and want to promote.
During a brainstorming session, a good friend (and eventual investor) said "What about Natty?". It was sitting right in front of us.
We resonated with the "Natty" gym culture, and loved how it tied in to our commitment to clean ingredients. The rest was history.
We had samples that people loved and we even started selling pints with our Natty sticker on them.
But we had a long way to go to get this ice cream into grocery stores.
Making ice cream for retail is completely different from making it at home. We needed to find a co-manufacturer.
We called several, and none of them worked out due to huge minimums, and/or unwillingness to make a protein ice cream with our standards.
We had one option, to build our own production facility. We took the leap, and ran into a big surprise.
Part 2 coming out soon!