Living through 2020-21 taught me that ideological manias have little to do with anything recognizable as "persuasion" or "intelligence" (super or not) and that having all public organs of information aligned doesn't do away with backlash polarization.
x.com/lukeburgis/status/2065…
It is incredibly easy for me to imagine AI Super Persuasion. I don't know how one could have lived through 2020-2021 and not be able to. It's not that humanity will be powerless, or that the individual human person will not be able to resist being persuaded, but the example Ross uses here of "70-30" is unconvincing to me—is the definition of "controversial that it has to be somewhere close to 50/50? And that is only for a moment in time, even so. The Overton window can shift fast, as we've all seen. But even more fundamentally, I believe in the Super Persuasion because I am haunted by the words of Christ, who asks "When the Son of Man comes again, will there be faith on earth?" It is very clear in scripture, at least, that there will be mass apostasy, and I don't know how that comes without some type of Super Persuasion. It seems extremely plausible that AI will play some role in it.