Neither until I see film…impossible question without film. And even then might be camp after to actually work with them and see how they are when I get to coach them myself and see how they move, carry themselves, follow direction, as a leader, confidence, comfort on the field.
So who are you taking as a coach and WHY!
You have 2 athletes with the “same” accolades, same comp, same eye candy etc they are very similar
Kid A
40 time is 4.41- lacks IQ, good footwork, just makes plays some how because of the system they have him in on the HS level, not good on the board with you on a visit.
Kid B
40 time is 4.56- great football IQ, puts guys in right place to make plays while making plays, good footwork, decent to good on the board with you.