For a while, I have watched some Nigerian Novus Ordo “mainstream Catholics,” clergy and faithful alike, such as
@frjamesa,
@FriarJ and
@UcheMaryOkoli, speak about sedevacantism in a way that clearly shows they do not understand what that term means or why the people who hold to that position do so.
Whether they do so out of wilful ignorance or genuine misunderstanding, I want to give them the benefit of the doubt.
Consequently, we have prepared a series of simple but in-depth explanations of what sedevacantism really is, as a response to an objector to that position.
Day 1: Why We Are Sedevacantists
Before we address the individual points, let us restate why we are sedevacantists.
Although we call ourselves sedevacantists, we are simply Roman Catholics who believe the papal office is vacant, and that those who have occupied it in recent years have been impostors, leading what is actually a New Church with a new religion; a new religion clearly defined by a rejection of several dogmas of Holy Mother Church and the embracing of several heresies and errors expressly condemned by the same Holy Mother Church.
A New Church that:
a. Contrary to the teaching that outside the Roman Catholic Church no one can be saved, teaches that non-Catholic churches are means of sanctification used by Christ, and acts accordingly toward them.
b. Contrary to the prohibition by the Church of active participation in religious worship with non-Catholics, encourages and fosters a false ecumenism that recognises common prayer and worship with non-Catholics, and recognises heretics as true shepherds of souls.
c. Contrary to the express condemnation of the Church that no false religion has a right to be freely practiced, teaches that civil governments commit evil by restraining the free and public expression of false religions within their states.
d. Contrary to the dogma that the pope alone enjoys supreme and universal authority over all Christians, teaches that in addition to the pope, the entire college of bishops also possesses this supreme power, so that the pope is obliged to accept whatever this college, as a body, teaches.
We are sedevacantists - Roman Catholics - because we profess the True faith in its totality.
We believe Jesus Christ founded the Catholic Church and committed to her all the means of salvation, and outside her, NO ONE CAN BE SAVED.
As Roman Catholics, we have seen the Church condemn those who rejected her authority and continue to pray for their conversion: Anglicans, Lutherans, Methodists, Eastern Orthodox, Jews, pagans, and so on.
That cannot, therefore, be the Church of Christ, the Mystical Body, if it contradicts what the Church has taught must be believed for centuries.
Okay. Let us agree that a new religion has been formed.
How is the Church still visible if for decades she has been without a pope, without a hierarchy, and all we see are several groups of people who claim to be traditional Catholics but who do not all agree on the same thing?
SEE YOU ON DAY 2!