As I have seen current governance, I think Cardano is repeating a mistake from the 20th century.
The socialist calculation debate concluded that "central committees cannot replace market price signals." All socialist nations failed to expand their economies in the 20th century. Yet our "Treasury governance" is making exactly this mistake.
Hayek's insight: prices compress the dispersed knowledge of millions of decision-makers. No committee, however expert, can process this information.
When DReps vote on marketing/commercial Treasury allocations, this is a political process replacing price discovery.
The irony: Cardano brands itself as "decentralization." But Treasury-based resource allocation, where political voting replaces market discovery, is structurally identical to central planning. Many DReps drawing from one central pool = Gosplan with a smiley face.
Public Choice theory also pointed out that bureaucrats who say "we serve the people" actually maximize their own budgets. "We need funding for the ecosystem" is the Cardano version of "we serve the workers."
We knew this type of economy always fails against free market capitalism. No one can be better than the invisible hand of the market. Commercial projects must be funded by profit-making entities with market expertise. DReps, on the other hand, are not directly responsible for outcomes of commercial/marketing projects. It's a wrong fit.
If we seriously want commercial/marketing success, don't be socialist. Let the economy be in the market's hands.
Stop repeating "Community, community, community."
We should think outside the box.
coffeepool.jp/notes/drep-vot…