1/2
Let me show you the price, me, as a clinician who care for patients and our community at large have to pay for publishing medical science to progress our knowledge regarding healthcare information and fight misinformation/disinformation.
Last year we published our brilliant report which detailed the painstaking clinical investigation that helped a young girl survive without a liver transplantation.
"Ayurvedic treatment induced severe alcoholic hepatitis and non-cirrhotic portal hypertension in a 14-year-old girl."
academic.oup.com/omcr/articl…
The girl suffered liver injury due to the Ayurvedic treatment (which she was on for seizures) leading to arsenic and alcohol poisoning over many years, which we reversed. The Ayurvedic meds were also adulterated with anti-seizure drug. This was the viral tweet on it.
twitter.com/theliverdr/statu…
Now the Ayurvedic practitioner K.P. Manikandan (
cnsayurveda.com/doctors.php) has threatened legal action against ALL authors of the study.
His conditions are as follows:
1/ I have to delete the peer-reviewed scientific paper from all online sources.
2/ I have to tender an unconditional and written apology to the Ayurveda practitioner.
3/ I have to pay 1,00,00,000 INR (USD 1,21,562) as compensation...
...without which they will commence civil and criminal proceedings against me and my co-authors, for publishing a factual, well-designed, exhaustively researched scientific report on how a young girl nearly lost her life to pseudoscientific treatments and how medical science salvaged her.
The use of legal threats and law machinery against well-meaning scientific discourses has been the most important reason why doctors in India, in general, do not speak up against Ayush pseudoscience mafia tactics. There may be many doctors in India who are seeing a lot of patients harmed by Ayurveda or Homeopathy but are keeping silent because they cannot fight the irrational and hostile tactics that the alternative medicine practitioners take them through.
This has to stop.
Arguments and debates on science and pseudoscience has to be on scientific platforms.
Continued...
A young girl & her father enters OPD
14y and is deeply jaundiced
Teary eyed, her father requests ONLY one thing
"She's advised liver transplant. We are poor. Can you please help us avoid it?"
I look at the girl the father
& brace myself for the worst case I'd ever seen...