Great take from
@NikoMcCarty on a terrific cell modeling study that came out in Cell this week. I was asked to comment for a news piece about it in Nature; here's the full text of what I wrote (with thoughts on AI-driven models vs more mechanistic models) in case it sparks further discussion:
Dear Ewen, thanks for reaching out and very exciting to see Zan and Zane's newest work! This work is a significant advance - the key part is including the kinetics, which most of the all-molecule simulations are not able to do. With regard to AI virtual cells, so far they are mostly promise and very little actual product, so it's hard to go into too much detail.
That said, one way to think about Zan's accomplishment is in the context of artificial life, or AL. Her lab and mine, and others, are focused on actually trying to build detailed representations of a living cell in silico. They are dynamic, holistic, and mechanistic, all of which adds many distinct advantages in contrast to what is being considered with AI.
For example, AL model simulations are explainable (that is, the simulated behaviors can be explained in terms of their mechanistic underpinnings), they actually require less data (but well-targeted, and of several different kinds), they are better suited to extrapolation, and interestingly, transfer learning is achieved through evolutionary theory (matching E. coli to a mycoplasma, for example), instead of (or in addition to) the traditional transfer learning methods that would be used for AI.
I anticipate that in the future, some of the best things we learn from AI and this next generation AL (first generation would be Conway's Game of Life, and stuff like that - but these new models move far beyond that) will be integrated, and that is an interesting future to consider. As my lab is currently demonstrating (to appear soon), these models can lead us to scientific questions that were never considered before, and making an impact in basic as well as applied science. Very exciting times!
* Note that several of these ideas came up in discussions with my lab members, they didn't all originate with me. Lucky to have a great team❤️
If you like this, then you may like my blog about biology:
nikomc.com.