I try to reply to people (who seem real / not bots), but sometimes I miss someone who leaves a good comment.
Cody Bellinger has proved he is probably worth the contract this season so far (although he ended up getting paid $162.5M).
How I was thinking about it at the time (back in January) is that the Yankees are only going to commit to spending so much money per season. $275M is the current 2026 payroll.
You're right that none of this is my money! I want the Yankees to spend $500M or a billion dollars if I had my way as a fan... But I know they realistically are going to end up at around $250-$350M probably over the next several years, so committing an extra $40M over a 5 year period isn't the end of the world, but the Yankees saved over the life of the contract ($162.5 M vs $200M he was angling for) enough so that the money could go towards other needs for the team. I WANT as much of that saved money going towards free agents and team development as possible. I do not desire that to just be "growth" or money in the owner's pockets. Again, I'm fan.
The team also can just use that to juice profits / choose not to spend the extra money at all. I think it's important as fans to not blindly defend the team being cheap / not paying someone, but it's not irrational for me to say that I want them to resign Cody Bellinger but understand the restrictions it might impose on future signings. Would those be worth it? At $162 M / how we've seen Cody Bellinger perform this year, hell yeah... I want that player signed. At $200M, he still would be worth the contract as he is proving this year, but it would restrict some things the Yankees would do whether we like it or not as fans.
I give 0 turtle shells about making the Steinbrenners richer or something. But I do want the best team possible for years to come. There's a balance. Pressure some rationality is where I land on it as a fan.
ALT Baseball Reference
ALT Jomboy Media graphic
Why? Why the hell not? What concern do you, or any fan, have about what someone gets paid? I don’t understand the obsession with payroll. It’s not our money. We have zero financial interest in the team. Yet, our cost for being fans increases annually regardless of the payroll.