Good point. I’d just add that, as usual, we wouldn’t be having this conversation if we’d enforce copyright laws at the outset. The lesson of the digital age is giving copyright exceptions to tech firms as a sort of industrial policy, just leads to bigger problems we have to sort out later. Every time! DMCA copyright safe harbor, Compulsory licensing for streaming, etc etc. Copyright law, rather than being outdated for the digital age, is the solution. More robust rights not less.
An AI tax that distributes AI companies’ ill-gotten gains just to the American people is an unfair and dangerous idea.
These companies are built on people’s work from all around the world. An AI tax would mean funneling wealth generated by extracting resources from other countries to US citizens. This is digital colonialism.
The *real* solution is simply to make AI companies pay for the training data they use. This means the money goes to the people whose work is actually exploited, wherever they are in the world.