As a former PM who ran a long/short vol strategy, I’ll say the quiet part out loud so that aspiring PMs out there know:
Long Vol / hedging funds are doomed to fail because you are asking allocators to pay a visible, recurring insurance premium for an invisible benefit.
Long-vol funds sell convexity, but allocators judge linearly
The experience is down month,
down month,
down month,
down quarter,
down year,
hey we're up some,
down month,
down month,
down month,
wait why are you pulling money there is a vol spike coming.
The better structure is a balanced portfolio with a clearly defined vol / convexity sleeve.
Let the core portfolio compound.
Let the convexity sleeve protect the left tail, create liquidity in stress, and fund rebalancing when assets get cheap.
Standalone hedging is psychologically hard to own.
Embedded convexity is much easier to underwrite.
There’s always a valuable lesson and a positive takeaway in every fund collapse.
I’m no volatility expert, and I hope someone does a thorough autopsy of what happened, but here are my immediate takeaways:
1) Tail risk hedging is really, really hard. There’s a reason the classic 60/40 stock/bond portfolio remains the most popular allocation in the world: the 40% in bonds is still the simplest, most reliable positively asymmetric long-term hedge most investors can implement. It’s not perfect, but it’s “good enough” for the vast majority of people who just want durable diversification without needing to be geniuses.
2) Shorting (and short vol strategies) is also really, really hard. You’re fighting the long-term upward drift of markets, dealing with asymmetric payoffs that require big moves to pay off, and battling time decay plus carrying costs. What looks elegant on a backtest becomes brutally difficult in live markets.
At the end of the day, the clearest lesson is this: investing is hard. You don't need to make it harder.
If you decide to actively trade, time the market, or run sophisticated strategies, understand that you’re voluntarily making an already difficult game even tougher. You might capture more upside along the way, but the margin for error shrinks.
I hope everyone finds some positivity in all of this.