People think that the data on antisemitism tells us how bad things are – as if it paints the whole picture. That couldn’t be further from the truth. In fact, the data on antisemitism, which major organizations, activists, scholars, and the media often obsess over, really doesn’t scratch the surface.
Every year, we hear about the hate crime statistics. Numbers go up. People express concern. Politicians make statements. And then we move on — as if counting the incidents we can measure tells us something meaningful about the full scope of what Jewish people (and their allies) are experiencing.
It doesn't.
Data captures *reported* things like assaults, vandalism, and egregious verbal statements – so long as they meet some arbitrary threshold. But data doesn't capture the look a Jewish kid gets when someone notices the Star of David around their neck. It doesn't capture the colleague who makes a remark at a dinner that everyone laughs off – but which the Jews at the table will never forget. It doesn't capture the sticker on the bus shelter that ruins your day before it's even started. It doesn't capture what it feels like to walk past a march where thousands of people are chanting slogans that call for the elimination of your homeland — and by extension, you.
It doesn't capture the parent who tells their child not to wear anything Jewish to school anymore. The professor whose classroom has become a place where Jewish identity is treated as something inflammatory. The conversation overheard at a coffee shop, where someone starts explaining why, actually, Hamas had a point. The data doesn’t mention the babysitter who stood in my living room in January 2024, and told me – in front of my family – that “Israel was gifted to the Jews.”
The most painful parts of antisemitism – of what we’re going through – rarely make it into a report. It lives in the spaces between data points — in the silences, the sidelong glances, the casual cruelties that Jews absorb daily and rarely bother discussing, because they've learned that nothing will happen anyway.
The numbers are alarming. The reality is worse.