As someone who mainly collects Pokémon cards, I think some people seriously underestimate just how big Pokémon is.
Don’t get me wrong, One Piece is clearly doing extremely well right now. But saying it’ll be worth more than Pokémon because Pokémon is running on nostalgia feels like a stretch.
A lot of the most popular Pokémon cards today aren’t even nostalgic vintage cards. Things like the 151 SV set cards, Evolving Skies Rayquaza, Moonbreon, Van Gogh Pikachu, and many of the modern Illustration Rares exploded because people genuinely love the artwork and the Pokémon themselves.
I also don’t think it’s accurate to say One Piece is more well known. One Piece has an incredibly passionate fanbase, but Pokémon is one of those franchises that’s recognized almost everywhere in the world, even by people who have never played the games or collected the cards. I could probably go to just about any third world country and hold up a picture of Pikachu and someone will recognize it.
Maybe there are One Piece collectors who see things differently, and I’d love to hear their perspective. But from where I stand as a Pokémon collector, I don’t see Pokémon going anywhere. It’s been one of the biggest franchises on the planet for decades (over $100 billion in lifetime revenue), and it’s still attracting new collectors today. The level of depth that the collector base holds is crazy - people collect every single little thing connected to the Pokémon TCG. Hell, a CGC 9.5 of the cardboard insert in the Ancient Mew promo packs just sold for $30 recently. Not the card itself- the damn cardboard insert that describes the card. The fanbase is ridiculous.
Could One Piece cards do really well? Absolutely.
But betting against Pokémon has been a losing bet for a very long time.
One Piece TCG > Pokemon
I feel like One Piece cards will be worth just as much, if not more than pokemon cards soon.
One piece is more well known, more fans grown people watch it and care about it.
Pokemon is mainly running off nostalgia fumes.
Investing in One Piece cards IMO is the move.