I find it to be absolutely confounding how Iran hawks think about this deal.
On one hand, they believe that the IRGC is a host of psychopaths with a religious zeal for bloodshed that is impossible to reason with.
And yet, on the other hand, they believe that a deal that gives Iran everything they've ever wanted. That Iran will make a deal that gives them everything—that the USA will just simply give them everything—in exchange for nothing?
I abhor the idea of a Memorandum of Understanding. I think it's a flatly ridiculous concept that defeats itself. It is self-assailing logic.
Iran is going to make the deal that we've quixotically hoped they would make for over 10 years now. But instead of making the deal? They need to... make a Memorandum of Understanding that will create the structure to negotiate the deal. And this Memorandum will take months to finalize with dozens of false starts along the way.
But someway, somehow, we are going to get past all of that and end up with Iran making a deal.
I am flummoxed by the idea anew every time I review it in my head.
And yet, I say all of this so that I can make it abundantly clear...
There is no deal.
So why is everyone panicking about a deal?
I'm miffed by the entire situation because I think it's patently ridiculous to start a war for a month, engage in a blockade for 2 months, and then just... hit the pause button for 2 months after that?
Nobody will make any sense of that for me.
But at the end of the day, is that some catastrophic outcome that warrants the hyperventilating you see in this post?
You think a deal won't resolve the nuclear issue? Great. Neither do I.
So lament this nonsense as the waste of time it's all-but-guaranteed to be. I'm all for it.
What I can't get behind is pretending that the whole thing is more than it is.
Netanyahu has decided to accept the Iranian deal. Security officials are despondent and see it as a disaster. Ynet brings some high level quotes from them:
1) A senior Israeli official said "Nobody is happy with this. We understand it is not good for us, and that it harms Israeli interests. What is troubling is that Israel cannot influence it. Its voice is not being heard."
2) The anger at Trump is palpable.: "Trump screwed us, we took the hit. We're no longer in the loop and can't really influence anything."
3) Israelis fear Iran will be economically revived: "They've blown money on the Iranians, who are getting everything they want. They'll build a missile corps, and we'll have to pour money into interceptors." Israel sees oil revenue flowing back into the exact capabilities the war was meant to degrade.
4) They don't believe a deal will adequately deal with the nuclear issue: "The real test of the deal is removing the uranium and destroying it. If that doesn't happen, the sense of a bad deal will turn into something more concrete."
5) They fear this will embolden Iran: "Iran has smelled that it can achieve things by force, and it will use that against its neighbors and against us."
6) The deepest worry is not military. It is perception. After months of direct fire, Iran is seen across the region as the side that took the pressure and did not fold: "the regional working assumption will be that it was signed under Iranian pressure and American capitulation, rather than the reverse."
Israel is concerned that Iran will be stronger, the US will be weaker and that the future for it will be bleak in the region. This war has been a disaster for Israel.