DISCLOSURE DAY, an oblong and unwieldy exploration of humanity's inalienable right to truth in a post-truth world and a speculation on the revelation of extra-terrestrial life is sadly one the most hollow and uninspired movies in Steven Spielberg's filmography.
The cast is fantastic, with Emily Blunt as the clear standout upon whom the entire movie hinges. Eve Hewson is a name I was not familiar with, but her character ended up being the one I found most interesting on a thematic level. Colman Domingo rocks.
94 year-old John Williams gave it his all with a beautiful, whimsical score that might not rival his best works, but still carried this movie beautifully.
While not a masterful example of Spielberg's legendary staging and blocking, Disclosure Day still looks good, because most of its scenes are well lit and Spielberg's action always has great clarity. It is undoubtedly one of the more visually enticing blockbusters of the year (highly questionable VFX aside), but at the same time, there's nothing here you haven't already seen in a superior manner throughout his filmography.
There is an action sequence involving a train which left me particularly disappointed, considering Spielberg made one of the greatest train scenes of all time in 1989.
The glaring VFX issues are even more apparent whenever the digital animals appear, breaking immersion completely. For me, this isn't a make it or break it issue; the design of the aliens however most certainly is! Mild spoilers ahead for something that was already somewhat visible in the trailers, but I was baffled that Spielberg would actually give us aliens that look like this --> 👽 in the year 2026. I love classic sci-fi stories, but Disclosure Day feels so stuck in the past at times, it becomes actively frustrating.
The uninteresting design of the aliens is sadly emblematic of Disclosure Day's biggest issue, which, is legendary screenwriter David Koepp's lackluster script. Too little of the movie actually revolves around its fascinating premise, as the few interesting ideas it has are drowned beneath endless chase and escape sequences. Its central plot never comes close to reaching the immense potential of its premise, its character journeys are never as interesting as they should be and its thematic exploration remains utterly shallow.
Frequently, background characters mention developments in international politics and in its third act, it is outright stated that Earth is on the cusp of World War III, but we never actually see any of it; none of these off-hand comments matter in the grand scheme of things. They are completely irrelevant to our characters and to the story being told. Some people will argue that's not what this movie is about (true!) but for a film that so often talks about the importance of its grand revelation to the 8 billion people of the world, its world-building is bafflingly amateurish and narratively inept, which can make the film feel cold and distant when it wants to be touching and inspiring.
Whenever the movie actually dares to venture into religious / philosophical territories, i.e. Christians in the face of other potential creations of their god or ponderings on humanity's right to know the full truth, I found it utterly fascinating. Sadly, there is just too little of it in its 2h 25minute runtime and some segments are quite frankly boring.
Its 3rd act is by far the strongest and whenever it fully embraces the beauty of its naive optimism & its relentless hopefulness, it is both engaging and touching. The final twenty minutes are pure Spielberg magic, but it's too little too late. Never have I seen a movie where the most interesting story it could have told is found on the 30-40 pages they never wrote.
This film's ending should have been the halfway point of its story, but Koepp & Spielberg are completely uninterested in *actually* showing us the world's reckoning with this great revelation. One of my biggest disappointments this year.
Now Watching: Steven Spielberg's DISCLOSURE DAY