H-1B ( There’s a difference )
One of the biggest misconceptions in the H-1B and foreign labor debate is the idea that a driver is “available” simply because they hold a CDL.
No. A driver is only available if they are willing to work under the pay, conditions, and lifestyle being offered.
If a trucking company cannot attract enough drivers, the first question should not be, “How do we import more labor?”
The first question should be, “Why don’t drivers want to work here?”
Before any company is allowed to claim a labor shortage, they should be required to demonstrate that they have made meaningful efforts to improve pay, benefits, working conditions, detention policies, home time, equipment quality, and overall treatment of drivers.
A company’s desire to haul more freight is not proof of a labor shortage.
A company’s desire to expand profits is not proof of a labor shortage.
A company’s inability to recruit drivers at the wages and conditions it wants to offer is not proof of a labor shortage.
In every other market, when demand exceeds supply, prices rise. Labor is no different.
If drivers are refusing the job, the answer may not be more visas. The answer may be creating jobs drivers actually want.
That’s not anti-immigrant. That’s basic economics.
A labor shortage exists when employers cannot find workers at competitive market wages and conditions. It does not exist simply because employers cannot find workers willing to accept less.
Just—A Driver’s Perspective