GBP rankings do NOT equal SERP rankings.
You need two different strategies, for two different algos.
And in some cases, different sites (if you have the resources)
This is EXACTLY how we're concurring both for a home service rollup right now:
(Bookmark to copy later)
The SERP algorithm rewards site architecture, link authority, content depth, and technical health.
The local algorithm rewards proximity, review velocity, brand mentions, social signals, and the relationship between physical addresses and search intent.
Different signals. Different strategies.
For this campaign, we're rolling out two strategies for the different sectors.
To target SERP rankings: clean architecture, schema, kill the crawl budget bloat, build location page clusters and TONS of links.
For the local pack: a satellite network of GBPs tied to local content.
The satellite play:
Since the client is PE-backed with HVAC, electrical, and plumbing divisions, we built standalone niche sites for adjacent service-area combinations.
Think of them as rank-and-rent properties except they're owned by the parent brand and funnel leads to the same CRM.
This is because the algorithm performs differently in this regard than it does for SERPs
You need a defined strategy that caters to the different signals.
Each node has its own domain, branded with city plus service keywords, with real reviews aggregated from the network.
These nodes target highly specific location verbiage to lock down specific regions in the market.
In their case, they're building dozens of these across their network now for each service and area they want to target with the local algorithm.
This is a 6-12 month strategy and with their review velocity the should be able to capture about 25% of the market for each service this year.
Most agencies we compete with only focus on one of the two algorithms.
But the reality is you can't split both into the campaign if you want true dominance, thats why we split it up for the highest impact when we have the budget for it.
This creates ironclad rankings that can't be matched by an agency with a linear strategy.