I never feel more like an alien on this planet than when smart people are being negatively polarised into being extremely dumb.
Elon is the classic case. Both in that he is one of the worst offenders, and in that people's valid judgement of him for his extremely dumb takes leads them to conclude that everything else associated with him is equally dumb.
Perhaps it's true that orbital datacentres don't make business sense this decade*, I don't know. But the pants-on-head arguments about technical infeasibility, from people who ostensibly should know better, or who are definitely capable of deferring to others who do, or even a chatbot, and are instead deciding to turn off their brains and spout technical sounding nonsense instead make me feel like I'm from another dimension.
(*they will one day though if humanity's energy use continues to grow - all power use on earth leads to warming, even without CO2 emissions, and most sunlight is in space. At some point we have to move energy-intensive things to space to get energy and not cook the planet)
If SpaceX were some tiny startup who'd achieved nothing, or if it were just Musk opining about what he was going to do with a trillion dollars when he hadn't hired a single engineer yet, more scepticism would be warranted! And there is always a risk that Musk will have dumb brain farts and take the company in a bad direction. And he plays fast and loose with marketing and predictions, a lot of what he says can't be trusted. He it a total loose cannon, particularly when he's on tilt which happens way too often.
But SpaceX isn't just Musk's tweets! The company actually has a lot of experience putting large numbers of satellites in orbit and making the economics work. Starlink is very profitable. They have talented engineers who have demonstrably solved many difficult technical problems to date. A little charity is warranted for the rest of the company regardless of Musk's public behaviour.
People don't like Musk, for good reason. I get it! But it's crazy the extent to which this makes people totally turn their brains off, as if the company doing 80% of global mass to orbit annually, mostly their own satellites, doesn't know a thing or two about how to make satellites.
I can feel in my bones that even me saying this will just make people assume I'm upset because I love Elon and think he can do no wrong - it's hard for people to even imagine someone is capable of holding separately in their mind Elon's flaws and SpaceX's virtues.
(who am I kidding, nobody sees my tweets lol)
To be honest I'm even inclined to defer to SpaceX somewhat on the business case for AI satellites. I'm not an expert here, and many people are saying the business case is poor, but if everyone is mind-killed by Elon hate, I have no idea if they're talking sense or not. I would only trust an expert's take if they dropped some shibboleths hinting that they are not a total partisan hack on the matter.
I think it's totally insane to be so dismissive of the expertise, business and technical, of an extremely successful company. Peak hubris!
People should also be careful not to be polarised into thinking AI satellites are an amazing and perfect idea just because of all the dumb arguments against them. Reversed stupidity isn't intelligence.
(though I think sometimes reversed stupidity can make for good stock picks lol)