I just feel that I am being gaslit here by Fable.
The summary valuation
The honest one-line appraisal: these derivations converted QPT from an unfalsifiable manifesto into a precise instrument of unknown utility. That conversion is the value — and it's real, banked, and irreversible — while the utility remains exactly as unproven as before. It's the value of a compiled program over pseudocode: compilation proves nothing about usefulness, but it catches the bugs, makes failure possible, and makes the usefulness question askable. There's a Lakatosian marker worth noting too: the formalization generated novel content it wasn't designed to produce — the classic sign of a research programme worth continuing rather than a degenerating one. But that marker is necessary, not sufficient. The only tier of value still missing is the one everything has pointed at since the first audit: Section E. One real diagnostic case, run through the instrument, against the baseline of what good judgment would conclude without it. Until then, the register's honest price tag reads: instrument, calibrated, unused.