Iām not talking just about what he did on the mountain, although the fact that this is the second woman heās abandoned on the exact same mountain does a lot to poke holes in the āhe just made a mistakeā argument just by itself. Iām talking about the totality of the behavioral evidence ā and while you may have been involved in a serious mountain drama, Iām a homicide investigator with 8 yearsā experience in one of the United Statesā most violent cities.
Consider: this man is a mountaineering expert. Heās been up this mountain before, as we know, and abandoned a previous girlfriend (after dark with her headlamp out) after expressing displeasure at her slow progress. He knows how hard this climb is even for an expert, but he decides that this should be his new gfās first experience.
Fine - I can buy that.
What I canāt buy is that this meticulous, controlling man fails to notice that his gf is wearing snowboarding boots, or that he fails to realize how much more difficult that would make things.
Thatās not all. He also insists that she carry a splitboard, which is worse than useless: in addition to being totally inappropriate for the terrain (which he knows, because heās been up this mountain before) the board adds weight to her heavy pack, and makes her colder. āCarrying a snowboard is like carrying an anchor,ā one climber told the BBC, and Plamberger would have known that, too.
They set out two hours late, reportedly with nothing by way of rations but gummi bears, and by 2200, she is in such bad shape that when rescue choppers are dispatched to aid them, in 5 minutesā observation, she only moves about 20-22 cm. Theyāre only about 1k feet from where they were seen at 1330, indicating significant and ongoing difficulties, which contradicts his statement that she was fine until 2230. Plamberger waves the chopper away. At 0035, he calls for rescue, but without communicating any urgency. He then puts his phone on vibrate and ignores repeated calls from rescue services as the conditions continue to deteriorate.
When he does abandon her, he makes no effort to aid her in any way. He doesnāt move her to a more sheltered area, much less use the emergency blankets or bivouac sack they were carrying. He doesnāt even take off her pack or the splitboard that would have been making her even colder. Instead, he leaves her on the open ridgeline, unprotected and hypothermic, and doesnāt call for help again until 0330, in spite of numerous attempts by rescuers to contact him. Additionally, her boots were open and her gloves off when she was found. (Thatās inconclusive, but I find it hard to believe that she would try remove her boots before taking off her pack.)